Stop Spamming the People You Want to Help
Cold email, cold calls and ad noise keep losing to a handshake. Here's what the numbers actually say.
Here's a confession from someone who has spent a whole career in tech: I think most of the digital outreach machine is broken. The automated email sequences, the "quick 15 minutes?" calls from numbers I don't know, the LinkedIn pitch that opens with my job title like it's a magic password. We built incredible tools to reach anybody, anywhere, anytime, and then we used them to make everybody tune out.
I'm not anti-technology. I'm anti-noise. And I'm an optimist, so I'll tell you where I think the signal still lives: in a room, with real people, shaking hands.
The inbox is a crowded beach
Think about the people you most want to reach: the CEO, the executive director, the person who actually signs off. Their inbox isn't a mailbox anymore; it's a crowded beach on the Fourth of July, and your carefully crafted message is one more towel in the sand.
The numbers back up the feeling. Microsoft's own data says the average worker gets about 117 emails a day, and most get skimmed in under a minute. Decision makers aren't average; they're the ones everybody is trying to reach. Woodpecker, a company that literally sells cold email software, reports a median reply rate of about 1.5%. Belkins, another outreach shop, found replies falling year over year and called C-level executives "the hardest to reach." When the people selling the shovels tell you the ground is hard, believe them.
Cold calls and title pitches
The phone isn't much better. Gong analyzed more than 300 million cold calls and found the average connect rate was 5.4%. That's roughly nineteen dials to get one human on the line, and that human is usually wondering how you got their number.
Then there's the title-based pitch. "As a VP of Something, you're probably struggling with Something Else." No, I'm probably struggling with the forty other messages that started the exact same way. People can smell a template from a mile away, and they've learned to filter it out.
Ads we've trained ourselves not to see
Same story with ads. We've all developed a kind of ad blindness, and that one isn't just my opinion. Nielsen Norman Group has documented "banner blindness" in eyetracking studies for decades: people's eyes skip right over anything that looks like an ad or sits where ads usually live. And for the folks who don't trust their eyes to do the filtering, eyeo estimates about 1.1 billion people, roughly 30% of internet users, now run ad blockers. My take is that the same instinct shows up everywhere else we get advertised at. Inundate people long enough and they don't get persuaded; they get good at ignoring you.
Showing up still works
So what does work? Showing up. Conferences, events, a coffee, a hallway conversation that wanders off topic in the best way. When you're standing in front of someone, you aren't a subject line. You're a person with a face, a laugh and probably a coffee stain.
There's research on this too. In studies by Mahdi Roghanizad and Vanessa Bohns, college students asked strangers to fill out a quick survey. More than 70% said yes when asked in person; about 2% said yes by email. That was a request, not a sales deal, but the human lesson travels well. It even holds at the very top: in a Harvard study of 27 big-company CEOs, 61% of their communication was face to face. And event pros feel it as well. In Bizzabo's 2025 survey, 78% of event organizers called in-person events their most impactful marketing channel. I'll be honest: that's their opinion, not a hard ROI number, and nobody I found has a clean head-to-head figure for events versus digital. But I'd bet on the handshake every time.
Don't spam the people you want to help
Here's the part that matters most to me. If you believe your product or your cause can genuinely help someone, why would you start that relationship by wasting their time? Spam isn't just ineffective; it's a little disrespectful. Gartner found 73% of B2B buyers actively avoid suppliers who send irrelevant outreach. The folks at Spamhaus put it even more simply: "Legal doesn't mean ethical."
Treat people the way you'd want to be treated. Earn the conversation. Go where they are, listen first, and give before you ask. That's not a growth hack. It's just being a decent human.
I'm grateful for every day God gives me, and I'd rather spend those days in real conversations than in a sequence of follow-ups nobody asked for. So close a few tabs, pause the automation and book the trip. Go shake some hands, ask good questions and remember people's kids' names. The inbox will still be there when you get back, and some of the best replies you'll ever get will be the ones that start with "Great to meet you last week."
Citations
- Microsoft WorkLab, "Breaking Down the Infinite Workday," 2025. microsoft.com
- Woodpecker, "Cold Email Benchmarks," 2026 (data from late 2025). woodpecker.co
- Belkins, "Cold Outreach Benchmarks 2025: The Belkins & Friends Report," 2025. belkins report (PDF)
- Gong, "The Hidden Power of Cold Calling: Insights from 300M Calls," 2024. gong.io
- Nielsen Norman Group, "Banner Blindness Revisited," 2018. nngroup.com
- eyeo, "Ad-Blocking Report 2026," 2026. eyeo.com (PDF)
- Scientific American, "In-Person Requests Are More Effective Than Electronic Ones," 2017 (on Roghanizad & Bohns, Journal of Experimental Social Psychology). scientificamerican.com
- Harvard Business Review, "How CEOs Manage Time" by Michael E. Porter and Nitin Nohria, 2018. hbr.org; figures as reported by CNBC, "Here's What CEOs Actually Do All Day," 2018. cnbc.com
- Bizzabo, "State of Events and Industry Benchmarks," 2025. bizzabo.com (PDF)
- Gartner, "Gartner Sales Survey Finds 61% of B2B Buyers Prefer a Rep-Free Buying Experience," 2025. gartner.com
- Spamhaus, "Spamhaus' Take on Cold Emailing…AKA Spam," 2025. spamhaus.org